traffic analysis

Thursday, May 24, 2007

A mosque in Rome so why not a church in Mecca?

The mosque in Rome

Not long ago, the idea of a mosque in Rome seemed preposterous. As the New York Times reported back in 1989 when the mosque was still under construction:

When the idea first came up more than five decades ago - building a mosque in Rome for subjects from Italy's colonial holdings in Africa - Benito Mussolini is reported to have said absolutely no.

When the idea first came up more than five decades ago - building a mosque in Rome for subjects from Italy's colonial holdings in Africa - Benito Mussolini is reported to have said absolutely no.

There will be a mosque in Rome, the Fascist ruler said, only when a Roman Catholic church is permitted in Mecca.

But, as the Times went on to report: "Not only is the first mosque now rising in the city of St. Peter, in a low-lying wooded area three and a half miles northeast of the Vatican, but it is also described by its Italian architects as the largest in Europe."

Whether or not this Roman mosque is the largest in Europe, as Abdul Qayuum Khan, then director of the Islamic Cultural Center in Rome told the Times in 1989, it is still the most important: ''The simple fact is that it is the only one located in the heart of Christianity, in the Mecca of Catholicism, you might say," he was reported as saying.

As one of the mosque's chief architects told the Times: ''For centuries, Islam and Christianity were in conflict. This is an expression of the opening of a dialogue among the different religions.''

As the Times went on to report:

The church dropped its objections [to having a mosque in Rome] after the Second Vatican Council in 1965. In the 1970's the Italian Government gave the Islamic center permission to build, and the Rome municipal government made a gift of a 7.5-acre undeveloped lot.
Saudi Arabia, custodian of the holy lands of Islam, footed the construction costs, estimated at $40 million and the mosque opened its doors in 1995.

More than a decade has now passed. Did the building of this mosque in Rome usher in the Islamic takeover of this traditional capital of Christendom?

Not as far as I can tell. This 2003 Christian Science Monitor report still seems largely accurate:

Islam has become the country's second-largest religion, with the number of Muslims estimated at 700,000 to 1 million among a total population of 57 million. Only 30,000 Muslims have Italian citizenship. The rest are labeled extracomunitari - working on temporary visas or illegally.

Unlike other religious communities, Italy's Muslims have yet to be formally recognized by the state. Other religions, including Judaism and smaller groups such as the Assemblies of God and the Seventh-Day Adventists, have signed agreements with the government, giving them official recognition and a chance to benefit from a national "religion tax."

Talks are under way to establish a formal dialogue, but observers warn that the Muslim community has yet to overcome internal divisions, and right-wing elements in the Italian government are intent on blocking all dialogue.

"There is a kind of resistance to formally recognizing that we are here," says Khalid Chaouki, president of the Young Muslims of Italy, complaining that some right-wing mayors refuse to authorize plans to build mosques and cemeteries. "It is very hard to make people realize we are people, not just Muslims."

Anyway, now that I've been in Rome for a few days and feel confident issuing opinions on the situation here, may I suggest that in order for Muslim's to gain full recognition of their humanity in this center of Christianity, they ought to consider building a church in Mecca. A move like this would certainly help persuade Christians that, well, they too are people, not just Christians.

Now speaking on behalf of the Vatican, I'm sure the Catholic Church would even be willing to fund such a project.